This post has the distinct possibility to be inflammatory. It is not intended to be that. It's intended to start discussions, not arguments, and to give you a little more insight into my life and into one of the more important aspects of my life--our church.
So why do I think it's better? The main answer is community. I have (personally) NEVER experienced community the way I do in my home church. So what do I mean by community? I mean people who will pull together to pay our bills for several months while we're unemployed. I mean people who will come to my daughter's 6th grade band concert. I mean having 5- and 6- hour dinners with friends every week. I mean game nights; intense fights and difficult reconciliations; vacations together. I mean people who have the freedom to discipline my children (and vice versa). I mean life together, really together, in all its glorious messiness. We are invested in each other, just like being part of a family. There are great times, and there are hard times. But we we deal with the hard times and work through them because, darn it, we're family. We have to live with these people, and we want to live with these people.
I realize a lot of things about this statement. First, it is my personal experience. Second, I am also fully aware that community--true, intimate life with others--is possible in many different venues, and home church does not hold a monopoly here. I also know that not everyone in my church knows this kind of community. But it's overwhelming to me, all-encompassing, and church and community are inseparable in my mind.
"Everyone" brings a song, a hymn, a word.
No one person has a monopoly--better word--on the word of/from the Lord, on the theology, on the rules. With, truly, no disrespect to those who are called to lead or attend a church with a traditional pastor, this model seems to me to lead to a sense that this person is more spiritual, more knowledgeable, more qualified, more responsible to seek and/or know the Lord than the rest of us. And I don't think that should be true, nor should it be our expectation.
As such, we church with people with more varied backgrounds and beliefs than I've known in church. Creationists, evolutionists, Church of Christ, Episcopal, Baptist--here there is no Jew or Greek, just those who are committed to loving God and loving people. Jesus is our common bond.
Variety. Our format follows patterns here and there, but there is also a wide variety of ways we gather together to do church. We have meetings dedicated to singing, dedicated to praying, dedicated to teaching the kids (the many, many kids), dedicated to teaching and/or to discussion. And we have meetings that are combinations of the above. We've square-danced, appreciated and created art, re-enacted the exodus, and sat quietly.
Realness. A lot of this stems from the community aspect--there can be no true community if people aren't real with each other. And realness is scary and messy and difficult. We've yelled and cried and argued and had hurt feelings. We've also laughed until we've cried and talked through very real problems and encouraged through the valleys. We push and pull each other along the way because we know each other. This is no country club, no social club. We are all freaks, and we know it.